Further speculation...

Sherwin-Williams is pretty awesome... I put together these color schemes on a model house online--ours actually looks a lot like this, even down to the reddish roof. This is the Weathered Shingle with the green trim mentioned earlier, and also with a blue trim, which we were planning on originally. I like both. The blue is so fresh and snappy! But is definitely leaning towards Colonial. The green is more historically accurate for Arts and Crafts/Four-Square. I could use some input.